Remember that time Zdeno Chara turnbuckled Max Pacioretty and got away with it?  Or that time Wayne Gretzky high sticked Doug Gilmour and then had the nerve to score the OT winner costing the Leafs a sure Stanley Cup (even though they still had a game 7 and blew that too)? This is where you finally get to use that really clever point you thought of 2 years too late.

Every week I post an old controversy and let everyone relive the rage.


If you have a historical Tough Call suggestion, e-mail me at or send a tweet to @ToughCallBlog